Education…Public vs. Private
May 28th, 2009
Over time, it has been shown that a private school education well exceeds a public school one, even in the same region of the country. There are many reasons why this is true. First we must look at the student body make-up of each learning environment as well as the differences in their approaches.
PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- Are required to take anyone living in the area and of the right age.
- Classroom size of about 30 students per instructor.
- Teachers are government employees.
- Movement and raises are standard and subjected to issues like seniority.
PRIVATE SCHOOLS
- Have selective enrollment.
- Can limit enrollment to keep class sizes down to about 20 students per instructor.
- Teachers are paid and moved based on performance and not seniority.
- Have chosen to teach in this environment, most of the time for a lower salary, because they enjoy teaching in a less rigid environment.
Understanding these differences is key to understanding the differences between the two systems as well as the quality of the education that is being gotten in both of these environments.
Traditional public schools tend to limit there learning to some specific areas such as math, and in government studies, math scores tend to be equal or better in the public school system than in similar private schools.
A study conducted by the Lubanski’s compared fourth grade and eighth grade math scores of 340,000 students in 13,000 public school systems across the United States. Private school students have been scoring higher on National Assessment exams for years, however, in this study, the public school students scored significantly higher than their private school counterparts.
Although this study does have some statistical significance, however, it is important to note that over time studies have shown that a better overall education can be had by students who attend private schools. And that other studies show that while the results in math are not significantly different between public and private schools, in the areas of grammar, reading, writing, and critical thinking, private schools show much higher scores and create better overall students with more moving on to higher education.
Overall, public schools can provide a decent education to the masses. However, private school will provide a more complete development of not only the student, but also the human being.



